Who is Sarah Cain, and why does she need saving? That’s the question posed in this Hallmark Channel-style film by Michael Landon Jr. The son of “Pa Ingalls” of Little House On the Prairie fame, Landon Jr. has started making a name for himself directing family-oriented fare that would make the Highway to Heaven star proud.
Saving Sarah Cain is an adaptation of the Beverly Lewis novel, The Redemption of Sarah Cain, in which an increasingly uninspired metro newspaper columnist attends the funeral of her Amish sister, only to find herself being granted guardianship of her sister’s five children. While being burdened the responsibilities of parenthood suddenly thrust upon her, she finds her nieces and nephews naiveté in dealing with the modern urban world charming and starts writing about her adventures raising them as they experience public school, Nike golf shoes and even videogames for the first time.
Suddenly, her career is back on the right path and just as everything seems to be going her way, it all begins falling apart. Working the faith theme in mildly in the background of the story, Saving Sarah Cain is a good-natured movie with its heart in the right place. However, it begins to fall apart in its failure to accurately portray people both in the Amish and the modern worlds.
The real trouble comes in the predictable plot, the paint-by-numbers dialog, and the black-and-white way in which the Amish (misunderstood angels) and the modern world (hardened and bitter bad guys) characters are portrayed. I mean, here are five kids who just lost their parents and they manage to be naïve, full of laughter and charm, and mostly positive throughout the piece. Does that ring true no matter how extreme the home school environment they were raised in might have been? The film’s handing of modern urban city dwellers is similarly one-dimensional.
Despite the film’s family-friendly nature and considerable charm, Saving Sarah Cain comes off as a movie with its head in the clouds and its feel floating well above real, hardened earth. It’s good for the younger set, but the patience of older, more worldly viewers might be tested by this nevertheless good-natured film. Oh, and don’t expect and DVD extras here; they’re nonexistent.



