One of the weaknesses of Sony’s NBA 06 for PlayStation 3 is the lack of roster accuracy. I always use the team I know best - the Minnesota Timberwolves - as a gauge of the desired roster accuracy. This season, that is an approach that is particularly effective, because of all the all-season changes to the Wolves’ roster.
There was, among other things, a complex 7-for-1 deal that sent franchise player Kevin Garnett to Boston in exchange for five players and two draft picks, off-season moves involving buying out the contract of Troy Hudson, trading Mike James to Houston for Juwan Howard, and the drafting of Corey Brewer.
NBA 08 for PS3 fails on at least two counts with Minnesota Timberwolves roster accuracy. Even after downloading the latest roster update from the PS3 Network, top draft pick Brewer is completely MIA in the game. Also, Hudson is still on the roster. The presence of Hudson might be forgivable, but considering Brewer was the number seven overall draft pick this summer, his omission is simply unforgivable from a roster accuracy standpoint. I searched other teams’ rosters and even the free agent wire and he’s simply not there. Intolerable!
From a game mode standpoint, Sony stubbornly refuses to add a franchise or dynasty mode to the game, meaning a single 82-game season with playoffs is all you get. This makes the inaccurate rosters even more objectionable. It also renders trades essentially meaningless because you can essentially stack a team to be good for one season and never have to worry about the long term good of the franchise. Refusing to offer a great franchise most is a pet peeve of mine and renders the game about as useless to me as if they included something ridiculous, like, oh, say, a shopping mode where you could buy golf apparel ladies and men enjoy.
Another disappointment is the player models. While Sony boasts NBA 08 is optimized for 1080p “True HD” display, the level of the graphics is still not where one might expect it to be, which lends the sense that if 2K Sports or even a “lousy at hoops titles” EA Sports ever got their act together, they could really blow NBA ‘08 out of the water.
Speaking of modes, the storytelling mode the company has experimented with the past two seasons, “The Life,” is replaced this season with a feature called “Game of the Week,” which actually pulls you out of your immersion in the franchise you’re choosing to run for a season.
All these objections stated, there are several good features in NBA ‘08. It offers a wide variety of online play options, for example, although during my time playtesting the game, I was unable to find a single online opponent, even once, with all the filters turned off! Granted, I received the review copy a bit early, but this was a huge disappointment and limited my ability to fully evaluate how the game played online.
The graphics are nice in 1080p, even if they still feel a bit too videogamey. I’d love to see a company serious about sports game graphics embrace 1080p and really rock my world with a near-photographic realism approach to an NBA game.
The controls work well in traditional mode, but the SixAxis motion controls were nothing to write home about. The sound work was fine, though lacking any real star power. And the music catalog was severely limited. I’d still love to see some sports game designer truly take advantage of the PS3 hard drive and allow you to import your own .mp3 collection into a sports game. I’d love to crash the boards to the sounds of Evanescence. Haven’t found it yet; if it’s here, I’m missing it.
The stat-tracking is minimal and ultimately, the strongest point to NBA 06 is the challenge level of the game. Sony does a good job of making opponents solid, not just videogame wireframes you can slip past easily to perform monster dunks.
Defense is palpable in the game and even on the easiest mode, the game AI will challenge you unless you have a couple great three-point shooters on your team and you’re skilled at hitting the money-wedge on the shot meter for those outside shots. But go up in game AI skill level and even that won’t be a help, since you’ll actually be challenged to play smart basketball and take wise shots.
So, once you’re on the court, NBA ‘06 actually plays pretty well. But when it comes to the details, the devil’s having his way with Sony, ruining a game that, if it were more accurate, had more and deeper modes and an active online community of devotees, could be a whole lot better than it is. For now, it’s a solid choice for casual game players, but not my pick of the season for dedicated NBA fans.